I have been struggling with my first serious scape for a while now and am feeling a little burnt out. I know this is a process, but I am past trying things on my own and desperately am looking for some help.
First a run down of my issues: Algae, poor growth (synonymous I'm sure)
Algae, primarily staghorn has been infesting my moss and some edges of leaves. I originally had 4x24W T5 HO's running, but i reduced lighting through several stages. Removed reflectors, swapped two bulbs for 4500k aquamedic planta bulbs instead of 6500k bulbs. My tank is deep, roughly 22" to the substrate, and i lost pearling on the HC, so i assumed it wasn't getting enough light...it also started to melt somewhat. I next added reflectors back but only to the planta bulbs. I actually saw a reduction in staghorn, however found that to be replaced with BGA. I had read that BGA prefers that spectrum. Next I did a 3 day blackout and rewired the ballast to run 2 bulbs instead of 4. I have been running one 6500k genesis grow bulb and one aquamedic planta bulb (4500k). Staghorn continues to grow, BGA was gone with the blackout. There is some GSA but not bad, at least compared to the staghorn.
Before adjusting lighting I was increasing my CO2. I'm fairly certain I have it as high as it can go since anytime I increase slightly my fish become stressed. I have done this over several weeks and cannot go further without seeing a change in my fish behavior. My CO2 is pressurized running through an inline reactor. I've been using a pH controller simply to avoid gassing my fish while adjusting. It is set to turn off CO2 at the pH where I have repeatedly observed my fish to become stressed from CO2 (hiding, swimming to the top) Over the course of a day i generally see the pH go from about 7.2 to 6.2. CO2 is on a timer, it starts one hour prior to lights turning on and turns off an hour prior to the lights turning off.
I have been dosing PMDD style EI + PO4 as described in the EI thread here for 2 months. My growth is poor for some species. My rotala macandra looks poor and it may be a deficiency but since EI is supposed to avoid that I'm not sure, nor do i know enough to identify the deficiency. HC has been melting away and not growing well. Part of it is i think during my DSM i over watered and some died off. New growth grew over that and left dead material underneath. I'm contemplating replanting the entire foreground and am open to suggestions on changing the plant. Perhaps with the depth I may have difficulty having enough light for the HC at the bottom and not too much for the moss at higher levels.
I have some holes in leaves in places and I'm assuming that is some of the snails who have stowed away on the plants. I am planning on adding a clown loach to eat the little buggers.. I have provided a picture in case these holes are the result of a deficiency.
I am willing to test anything people suggest. I have a redsea freshwater deluxe kit and i remember reading testing can be a bit ambiguous without standards to compare results to...but I will test with it if someone suggests it.
Here are pictures of what I'm talking about:
View attachment 1792View attachment 1793View attachment 1794View attachment 1795View attachment 1796
Thank you to all who are willing to help me work on this tank. I hope that through this first tank I can troubleshoot the common problems and learn in order to create trouble free scapes in the future.
First a run down of my issues: Algae, poor growth (synonymous I'm sure)
Algae, primarily staghorn has been infesting my moss and some edges of leaves. I originally had 4x24W T5 HO's running, but i reduced lighting through several stages. Removed reflectors, swapped two bulbs for 4500k aquamedic planta bulbs instead of 6500k bulbs. My tank is deep, roughly 22" to the substrate, and i lost pearling on the HC, so i assumed it wasn't getting enough light...it also started to melt somewhat. I next added reflectors back but only to the planta bulbs. I actually saw a reduction in staghorn, however found that to be replaced with BGA. I had read that BGA prefers that spectrum. Next I did a 3 day blackout and rewired the ballast to run 2 bulbs instead of 4. I have been running one 6500k genesis grow bulb and one aquamedic planta bulb (4500k). Staghorn continues to grow, BGA was gone with the blackout. There is some GSA but not bad, at least compared to the staghorn.
Before adjusting lighting I was increasing my CO2. I'm fairly certain I have it as high as it can go since anytime I increase slightly my fish become stressed. I have done this over several weeks and cannot go further without seeing a change in my fish behavior. My CO2 is pressurized running through an inline reactor. I've been using a pH controller simply to avoid gassing my fish while adjusting. It is set to turn off CO2 at the pH where I have repeatedly observed my fish to become stressed from CO2 (hiding, swimming to the top) Over the course of a day i generally see the pH go from about 7.2 to 6.2. CO2 is on a timer, it starts one hour prior to lights turning on and turns off an hour prior to the lights turning off.
I have been dosing PMDD style EI + PO4 as described in the EI thread here for 2 months. My growth is poor for some species. My rotala macandra looks poor and it may be a deficiency but since EI is supposed to avoid that I'm not sure, nor do i know enough to identify the deficiency. HC has been melting away and not growing well. Part of it is i think during my DSM i over watered and some died off. New growth grew over that and left dead material underneath. I'm contemplating replanting the entire foreground and am open to suggestions on changing the plant. Perhaps with the depth I may have difficulty having enough light for the HC at the bottom and not too much for the moss at higher levels.
I have some holes in leaves in places and I'm assuming that is some of the snails who have stowed away on the plants. I am planning on adding a clown loach to eat the little buggers.. I have provided a picture in case these holes are the result of a deficiency.
I am willing to test anything people suggest. I have a redsea freshwater deluxe kit and i remember reading testing can be a bit ambiguous without standards to compare results to...but I will test with it if someone suggests it.
Here are pictures of what I'm talking about:
View attachment 1792View attachment 1793View attachment 1794View attachment 1795View attachment 1796
Thank you to all who are willing to help me work on this tank. I hope that through this first tank I can troubleshoot the common problems and learn in order to create trouble free scapes in the future.
Last edited by a moderator: