Help with home made substrate for aquatic plants

issis

Junior Poster
Apr 25, 2011
4
0
1
41
Hi,

Presently I have a 22 gallon tank with plain grave(3-4mm) as substrate. I pump in CO2 using a DIY yeast method. I get about 5-6 bubbles every 5 seconds. I have amazon swords and Hygrophila corymbosa, planning to have Hygrophila difformis and HC "cuba" as well.

As observed the substrate is not sufficient in providing the plants with enough nutrition. The swords are all yellow and brittle at the tips, suggesting a deficiency of iron (or sulphur?).

So, I've decided to change the substrate as a whole. Since the well known substrates such as ADA, aquasoil etc are not available in my region, I'm planning on creating my own as follows:

  1. I've got some garden soil rich in humus and red soil. I plan to mix the two and wash the mixture by keeping it in a bucket filled with water up-to 2-3 inches above the soil surface, let it soak for 1 day and rinse it, repeating this step 4-5 times.
  2. Place this mixture at the bottom layer in the tank, having a height of 2 inches, and top it up with gravel of size 2-3mm for a height of 1 inch.
  3. I plan to dose the tank twice a week with a weak solution of Epsom salt, potassium sulfate and salt peter, about 2-3 teaspoons.
  4. Regular 30% water changes once a week.

My questions are:
  1. Will this substrate with regular dosing of the fertilizer solution keep my plants healthy(I provide sufficient lighting as well)?
  2. Since I plan to grow HC (I will try the DSM) gravel may not be a good option for the top layer. But if I use the garden soil-red soil mixture alone, won't it cloud the water when the tank is filled up, assuming HC has carpeted most of the tank area?

Thanks!
 

jonny_ftm

Guru Class Expert
Mar 5, 2009
821
2
16
You don't add micro or PO4 in your dosing. In my experience, even with organic soil, you have to dose EI

Gravel and HC are not friends. Sand is much better for this.

I won't keep organic soil exposed: it could leak too much ammonia and would be a pain to plant without spreading debris in all tank. Could be deadly for fish and heaven for algae

You have to boil your soil to avoid parasites. Just take a look at the earthworm castings thread and follow the same method

Finally, I'll use a thicker top sand layer over organic soil, up to 2 inches