Fish in planted tank

martinphillip03

Lifetime Members
Lifetime Member
Jan 6, 2006
25
0
1
62
A, A
I am starting a planted angel tank. Should I add fish that eat algea. If so what types should I put in.
55 gal, pressurized co2, flourite, 2.5 watts/gallon

thanks

Marty
 

colonel

Guru Class Expert
Nov 25, 2005
118
0
16
Re: Fish in planted tank

Well I guess that really all depends... is there algae in the tank for the fish to eat? LoL, Really its a matter of personal preference, many find having a "maintenance" crew of sorts to be of great use. There are a lot of fish you could add to help with the algae my favorites are Siamese algae eaters, one of the few fish that will really eat the dreaded BBA. Oto. sp. and bristle nose pleco's. There are lots of others that folks have had luck with eating one type or another of algae that are sometimes recomened. Those listed are really the only ones I ever keep and they do a fine job... usually in most of my tanks I only keep some Oto's on hand. If it is a well run, healthy tank algae shouldnt be much of a problem at all and there really shouldnt be much of a need for it to be removed. Good luck!
Matt
 

metasyntax

Junior Poster
Mar 11, 2005
18
0
1
Richmond Hill, Ontario, Canada
Re: Fish in planted tank

I've found that SAE's need a big tank real quick and might be too distracting from the slower moving Angelfish. Mine played tag all day!

I'd tell you to start with amano shrimp (1 for every 1-2g of actual water in your tank). They seem quite hardy to me, and are fairly cheap. You could go with cherry shrimp as well, but they tend to be more expensive for some reason.

Once your tank is well established, evaluate how much algae you have on the various surfaces, and then get some otto cats if nesecary. I've found them quite sensitive, and have had better luck adding them to an established tank.

IMO and all that,
meta
 

martinphillip03

Lifetime Members
Lifetime Member
Jan 6, 2006
25
0
1
62
A, A
Re: Fish in planted tank

The one problem I have with otto's is my angelfish will swallow them, get caught in the throat, then die. it happened twice to me. I might try the shrimp route. But they probably fare any better.

Marty



metasyntax said:
I've found that SAE's need a big tank real quick and might be too distracting from the slower moving Angelfish. Mine played tag all day!

I'd tell you to start with amano shrimp (1 for every 1-2g of actual water in your tank). They seem quite hardy to me, and are fairly cheap. You could go with cherry shrimp as well, but they tend to be more expensive for some reason.

Once your tank is well established, evaluate how much algae you have on the various surfaces, and then get some otto cats if nesecary. I've found them quite sensitive, and have had better luck adding them to an established tank.

IMO and all that,
meta
 

Tom Barr

Founder
Staff member
Administrator
Jan 23, 2005
18,695
736
113
Re: Fish in planted tank

Angels love shrimp FYI.

I'd go with rubbernoses, bushy noses etc, they also have the giant otto cats sometimes, they are about 3x the size.

algae eating fish/critters are not required, but they do provide some extra help with subtle issues, they basically are icing on a cake, not the main method to addrerss algae.

That should always be done through improving the growth of the plants, when the plants are not happy, algae comes every time.

Regards,
Tom Barr
 

srozell

Guru Class Expert
Jan 24, 2005
110
0
16
Re: Fish in planted tank

Rosy barbs also help with various types of algae.
 

richr

Junior Poster
Jan 20, 2006
14
0
1
Re: Fish in planted tank

Anyone have experience with twig catfish - Farlowella acus?