eBay Drop Checker arrived, but...

Detritus Mulm

Guru Class Expert
Jun 12, 2005
147
0
16
My Drop Checker arrived from H.K. with a shiny bottle of Blue Water, but zero instructions. So I'm assuming the Blue Water is premixed reference solution and not PH solution. It looks too light to be PH solution and there is too much to be PH solution. There is enough in the bottle for about two fillls of the little light bulb glass.

So far though the colour is staying blue (1 hr) and does not match any of the colurs on the enclosed PH chart (light green for 6). Any thoughts or experience with this checker.
 
If the "blue water" you refer to came in a small, 10ml dropper bottle, then that is your indicator solution.

You need to mix up (or buy from Bill) a 4KH solution. Add a couple ml of that to your drop checker then add a couple of drops of the blue indicator solution that came with the drop checker.

You will notice color changes in an hour or two.
 

Detritus Mulm

Guru Class Expert
Jun 12, 2005
147
0
16
Bartman;14621 said:
If the "blue water" you refer to came in a small, 10ml dropper bottle, then that is your indicator solution.

You need to mix up (or buy from Bill) a 4KH solution. Add a couple ml of that to your drop checker then add a couple of drops of the blue indicator solution that came with the drop checker.

You will notice color changes in an hour or two.

I was hoping this was not the case. But it makes sense based on what I'm seeing.

Thanks.
 

VaughnH

Lifetime Charter Member
Lifetime Member
Jan 24, 2005
3,011
94
48
85
Sacramento, CA
If you have a pH test kit that gives a yellow color at about 6pH and blue at about 7.2 pH, such as the Aquarium Pharmaceuticals test kit, you can use that test reagent. I am not impressed by the reagent sent out with the ebay drop checker. From what you are describing I wonder just what the stuff in the bottle you have really is. Bromothymol Blue indicator, which it should be, is yellow in the reagent bottle, but turns blue in typical tap water.
 

Tom Barr

Founder
Staff member
Administrator
Jan 23, 2005
18,696
745
113
Bromo blue is what you should be using, I use the 3 drops of Bromo blue+ 6mls of 4KH(71.44ppm) solution inside there.
Bromo blue is cheap.

You can vary this, but this amount is a good general range and should be changed out every 2 weeks or if you get tank water etc inside.

Light photo degrades Bromo blue to some degree also.
Not sure how much.

Regards,
Tom Barr
 

Detritus Mulm

Guru Class Expert
Jun 12, 2005
147
0
16
VaughnH;14626 said:
If you have a pH test kit that gives a yellow color at about 6pH and blue at about 7.2 pH, such as the Aquarium Pharmaceuticals test kit, you can use that test reagent. I am not impressed by the reagent sent out with the ebay drop checker. From what you are describing I wonder just what the stuff in the bottle you have really is. Bromothymol Blue indicator, which it should be, is yellow in the reagent bottle, but turns blue in typical tap water.

Not sure, this stuff is Blue in the bottle and the colour sheet ranges from 6 to 10. I thought Bromo Blue stopped at about 7.4.
 
I got the same thing you did I think. Did it come in a white bottle with green lettering?

It seemed to work for me in the 4KH reference sol'n, but it's tough to tell exactly what pH you're at since each color change indicates a 1 pH step.

I just changed out to bromo blue last night and I think its easier to get a more accurate reading with it.

At 30 ppm CO2 in 4Kh solution you will have a pH of 6.6 which is right in the good range for bromo blue.
 

Detritus Mulm

Guru Class Expert
Jun 12, 2005
147
0
16
Bartman;14698 said:
I got the same thing you did I think. Did it come in a white bottle with green lettering?

It seemed to work for me in the 4KH reference sol'n, but it's tough to tell exactly what pH you're at since each color change indicates a 1 pH step.

I just changed out to bromo blue last night and I think its easier to get a more accurate reading with it.

At 30 ppm CO2 in 4Kh solution you will have a pH of 6.6 which is right in the good range for bromo blue.

Sounds like the same stuff.

Did you get your Bromo Blue and KH Reference from the same place?
 
I got my KH standards from Bill. You can find more info on them in the Sale/Swaps forum. He's got a thread called "KH Standards" with more info on. It was fast and reasonably priced.

The bromo blue I got was the Red Sea CO2 checker drops (I'm pretty sure its bromo). I got it from my LFS for $3-4 for a 10ml bottle.

Does anyone know if the Aquarium Pharmaceuticals "pH Indicator Solution" is bromo blue? It seems about right because the indicator card that comes with it shows a color change from yellow at 6.0 to dark blue at 7.6.

The Aq Pharm pH checker runs about $5 for 1.25oz (37ml). You can find it at many LFS or online at places like Big Al's and That Fish Place. It may be a cheaper option than the co2 checker drops, plus it comes with a color chart. You'd probably want to check it against a standard to get a more accurate idea of what pH the colors match up to.

Tom Barr and others may know of cheaper sources of bromo blue.
 

VaughnH

Lifetime Charter Member
Lifetime Member
Jan 24, 2005
3,011
94
48
85
Sacramento, CA
The AP pH test reagent is bromo blue. It's the one I use. It is possible to buy bromothymol blue from chemical supply places, but what you get isn't a test reagent. It is a dye, which you then have to mix your own reagent with. Maybe it's cheaper, but it sure is a lot more work for a lot more reagent than you could possibly use.
 

WAX

Junior Poster
Feb 25, 2007
19
0
1
47
indiana
i have the red sea drop checker and it tells me to use 1 ml of the aquarium water and the two drops of the reagent. should i also use the 4KH solution and not the aquarium water?
 
Yes use a 4KH standard. Your readings will be more accurate. Other substances in your aquarium water can change the pH and could give you a different pH reading for a given CO2 concentration.

There are quite a few good links that can give you lots of details if you want to read more. Here are two for you to start with.

http://www.barrreport.com/articles/2661-drop-checkers-co2-indicators-why-how.html

http://www.barrreport.com/co2-aquatic-plant-fertilization/2289-old-co2-idea-good-new-idea.html
 

Tom Barr

Founder
Staff member
Administrator
Jan 23, 2005
18,696
745
113
How accurate can you get with 1 ml measurements and drops? :cool:

I'd rather use more liquid KH solution and drops, that will reduce some error but.......longer response time.
So that's the trade off there.

Regards,
Tom Barr